Atlanta

Cheated on Jessica the entire time with fellow cast member LC while playing the devoted nice guy

Said no to Gigi at the altar after a tearful speech, then strung her along post-show

Explosive poolside blowup with Diamond — threw the engagement ring in the pool

Led on multiple women (Jessica, LC, Amber) before finally committing

Baby voice, fed her dog wine, constantly pined for Barnett while engaged to Mark

Threatened to break Jessica's nose... twice. Ex-military energy was real

Blindsided Kenny at the altar after seeming totally in love